The ultimate cold email checklist
What you need to know before you send your first cold email.
We designed our tool to help you ensure maximum deliverability!
1. Never use your own domain
You are going to do things wrong and it’s too risky to use your primary professional domain.
You could use G Suite with a new domain.
When getting a new domain, you could be put into a spamlist (fresh) automatically. It’s only for higher risk of spam and it lasts about 1 month before you’re automatically de-listed. You can use lesser-known extensions (as opposed to .com) to avoid this, as not all extensions are monitored.
2. Never use a free email account
Free gmail accounts (@gmail.com) are blocked quickly when a mistake is made, with no possibilities to re-open them.
With professional accounts like G Suite, you have access to business support in case your account is blocked.
3. Use Outlook/Office 365 as an email provider for best deliverability
We’ve tested many email providers and as of this year, Office 365 is the best email provider in terms of deliverability. We recommend creating a professional business email account with them and using QuickMail to automate.
If you have to stay on GSuite: Sending follow-ups will increase your volume quickly, so do plan that in advance.
By default, all G Suite accounts are limited to 500 emails per day until you reach $30 in billing.
Pre-pay $30 to unlock 2,000/day to avoid bounces from gmail when your volume will increase with follow-up.
4. Make sure SPF and DKIM are set for your domain
5. Check your deliverability
Use services like mail-tester.com to determine your deliverability score. Then look at how it can be improved by addressing all of their recommendations.
6. Make sure emails do exist prior to sending
It’s of utter importance to make sure the email addresses you have won’t bounce. Google and other mail providers will block your account quickly. Bounce = spammer. So make sure you have all the right emails.
Never buy lists, and make sure you always use services like BriteVerify or Kickbox to clear your list first.
7. Avoid similar content
Similar content gets flagged as spam. Use custom attributes to make sure each email is unique and create a few different email variations (like A/B testing).
8. Delay message sending
By default, QuickMail.io spaces out emails by 30 seconds (you can always increase this number). The higher the number, the less likely you’ll be to be flagged as spam.
9. Don’t add images in the first email
Don’t add images in your first touch email if you can avoid it. Usually the text on the first email is short. Adding an image has a bad text-to-image ratio, and spam filters don’t like that.
Tracking pixels (to determine open rate) are images. So to increase deliverability, you will need to disable the tracking of opens in the first message.
Once follow-ups kick in, there will be enough text so that the ratio is not completely off.
10. No more than 1 link per email, and don’t mask links.
If you track links, make sure they’re not coming from a shortening service (e.g Bit.ly). Those are likely to be listed in spam lists already. Spammers use these link shortening techniques all the time, and you don’t want to be lumped in with the spammers.
Use description instead of URL. For example, if your link is www.mydomain.com, use “My Domain”… don’t put “www.mydomain.com,” as the tracking link will point to another address and services will often think it’s a phishing attack. Either write the URL without making a clickable link, or disable click tracking in the first message.
11. Don’t contact more than 50 people/day
If you do it right, you can get around a 20% reply rate.
No need to max out Gmail’s limit.
– It’s hard to find 2k valid emails that won’t bounce each day
– You don’t have the bandwidth to seriously engage with 400 replies anyway
Don’t go for quantity, as you’ll be punished in many ways. Try to nail it down with low volume first.
12. Avoid unusual burst of emails
It’s way better to send each day 50 emails, than to send 250 emails one day a week.
Spam filters pay attention to things that are out of the ordinary. So to fly under the radar, have a continuous amount of emails sent daily rather than a one-time event that may be caught.
13. Only send to individuals
Send to individual addresses, not groups such as marketing@, info@, sales@ … if you do, you’ll run the chance of getting flagged as a spammer.
14. Don’t sell on first email
The goal of cold emails is to engage in a conversation, not to get a sale from the first email. It’s best to sell only once you’ve created a relationship; not before.
People who try to sell right away get flagged as spam super fast, and future emails will end up in junk folders.
15. Don’t repeat yourself in a follow-up
Include the previous email for context, and provide a different call to action. Remember to always add new value with each follow-up.
16. Type as if it was text only
It’s not a beauty contest. Write like a human. No color, no bullet points, bold text, or custom fonts… resist the urge!
17. Use business emails, not personal emails
Avoid @yahoo.com, @gmail.com and other free type of emails, as they are more likely to be personal emails and not business. Personal email addressed with business activities lead to greater spam complains. E.g. launching a KickStarter campaign with cold email from your personal address should be avoided.
Learn the secrets behind users with 50%+ reply rate and avoid common pitfalls with this high value packed, straightforward and essential book to be successful faster with outbound emails.
All QuickMail yearly plans come with a free kindle version.